Join In On The Action "Register Here" To View The Forums

Already a Member Login Here

Board index Forum Index
User avatar
NASCAR Driver (Pro V)
 
Posts: 7838
Joined: 08 Apr 2002, 9:45 am

Post 14 Jan 2014, 12:58 pm

A note regarding the misorders:

- The Austrian order of Gal instread of Boh is an invalid order.
- The English support of MAO to SPA (SC) is valid even though the support order does not designate the coast.
- The English order of Ber (instead of Bur) is very unfortunate as the real Ber has an English occupant as well. There are now two orders for Ber and neither will count.

All three of these situations were passed through the tournament committee and the results represent their unanimous decision. I implore you to double and triple check your orders.

Fall 1908

:aus1: Austria: machmstr
WAR SUPPORT MOS (ok)
MOS H (ok)
PRU M BER (bounce)
VIE M BUD (ok)
ADR SUPPORT VEN (ok)
VEN SUPPORT TYR (ok)
TYR SUPPORT GAL M MUN (invalid order)
GAL M MUN (invalid order)

:eng1: England: Sassenach
F WES S F MAO – Spa (ok)
F IRI – MAO (ok)
F BAR S A StP (ok)
F BAL S A Ber (ok)
A Ber S A Mun (multiple orders / invalid)
A Kie S A Mun (ok)
A Ber – Par (multiple orders / invalid)
F Eng hold (ok)
A StP hold (ok)

:fra1: France: gpw
A Munich Holds (ok)
A Piedmont – Marseilles (ok)
A Tuscany – Piedmont (ok)
F Gulf of Lyon - Spain (sc) (bounce)
F Mid-Atlantic - Spain (sc) (ok)
F Tunis Supports F Tyherrian Sea - Ionian Sea (ok)
F Tyherrian Sea - Ionian Sea (bounce)

:ger1: Germany: jediknight Eliminated

:ita1: Italy: freeman3
Army Rome supports Army Naples (ok)
Army Naples supports Army Rome (ok)

:rus1: Russia: patrickpweeks Eliminated

:tur1: Turkey: Javelin
Army Ukraine – Galicia (ok)
Army Sevatopol S (Austrian) Army Moscow (ok)
Fleet Black Sea S Army Sevastopol (ok)
Fleet Apulia S (Austrian) Army Venice (ok)
Fleet Ionian S Fleet Apulia (ok)
Fleet Aegean S Fleet Ionian (ok)

Retreats: None

Winter 1908 Deadline: Thursday, January 16th @ 1 p.m. EST or 6 p.m. GMT

Austria: 8 SC’s / 8 units
No change

England: 10 SC’s / 9 units
Build one

France: 8 SC’s / 7 SC’s
Build one

Italy: 2 SC’s / 2 units
No change

Turkey: 6 SC’s / 6 units
No change

Maps

Image

Image
User avatar
Emissary
 
Posts: 3405
Joined: 12 Jun 2006, 2:01 am

Post 14 Jan 2014, 3:24 pm

Hmm...

Ok, so that was ultimately my own fault. I don't have to use the shorthand, plenty of players don't and now I see why. It's also my own fault for being so soft that I couldn't bring myself to make the stab on Christmas Eve when I was actually better placed to do it. Still though, it seems like an incredibly harsh decision. There wasn't any ambiguity in the order. It was quite clear what I meant and also quite clear to Mike that it wasn't a deliberate misorder because I mentioned in my email to him that I was finally instituting the long overdue stab. As such I think it would have been fairer to let that move stand. For the sake of a typo I've been heavily disadvantaged.

Btw, sorry Greg. You knew it was coming I'm sure, but still. Would have been nice to avoid this but we were clearly going nowhere.