Neal Anderth wrote:I'm going to repeat myself by again sharing a bit of the Constitution:
First Amendment – "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."
Any action by the government or its agents to the contrary is invalid.
I would emphasize the word "peaceably." When they are defying valid dispersal orders because of city ordinances, private property, public health, etc., the actions of the government are not "invalid." Now, they may be challenged in court, but they should not be challenged by mob action.
geojanes, the protesters are in D.C. too. Thanks for your additional comments regarding Liberty Plaza.
However, logically, the protests ought to be entitled "Occupy DC." That's where the problem is. Wall Street didn't bail itself out. Wall Street cannot engage in crony capitalism without a willing partner--one who is supposed to be the People's voice.
If it wasn't for the police interventions this whole thing would likely be over with already. When you tell people they can't do something they believe they should be free to do it gets them riled up.
That's one perspective. The other would be that when you have a core (however large or small the core may be) of protesters who are either socialists, communists, or anarchists, they won't easily give in.
Again, look at the Tea Party protests. They were bigger, but we didn't see these kind of confrontations. Why not?
Meanwhile, Oakland, which is broke, has spent more than $1M on the protests.
Moveon.org: "Power to the people!" (everyone chant!)
Either these people are useful idiots or those organizations (like moveon) are foolishly stirring the pot and hoping revolution and/or riots don't result.
The sooner OWS ends or becomes a legitimate sub-group of the Democratic Party (like the Tea Party did with the GOP), the better. Street mobs of the sort we see now, will not be a "good" thing.